Luca - Is It Good or Nah? (Pixar Review)

89 000 Views 1.5M

Comments

  1. Unknown
    Unknown
    Hour ago

    I honestly don't agree with the point that Alberto was a jerk I mean they kinda left the poor guy out and he barely knew anything about above surface so it's kinda understandable that he is jelous as his friend is being taken by gulia. Also just cause he was a slight jerk doesn't mean u leave u r friend for dead

  2. TexMechs
    TexMechs
    6 hours ago

    I really enjoyed this movie. It was just so simple and fun. A bit messy at the end but all around great.

  3. PatchworkRose567
    PatchworkRose567
    8 hours ago

    Luca is a fun, simplistic movie that reminds me of hanging out with friends and learning how relationships and the world works as a child. It also has a fun, children’s book art style to it

  4. Viper
    Viper
    Day ago

    It took me this long to realize the thumbnail has the octopus from Shark Tale in the bottom left corner.

  5. balashibu yeeter
    balashibu yeeter
    Day ago

    Bad batch supremacy

  6. TMGClips
    TMGClips
    Day ago

    though I think the film is very good and charming, the film does seem rushed

  7. izuchan
    izuchan
    Day ago

    Who else is here after Chris Stuckmann's terrible review?

    1. Zeeshan Aliawan
      Zeeshan Aliawan
      16 hours ago

      Meeee

  8. PayBaf PVZimp
    PayBaf PVZimp
    Day ago

    Where is it on the Pixar ranking

  9. Mister WiZeguy
    Mister WiZeguy
    Day ago

    Honestly, my favorite part of the whole movie was the end credits. And I’m not being sarcastic. If you’ve seen the movie, you know what I’m talking about.

  10. TheSpiceAndRice
    TheSpiceAndRice
    2 days ago

    They really didn’t need to be fish people for this movie to get its point across. I wanted to dive more into the world of the fish people. Seems like a wasted opportunity to me 🤷‍♀️

  11. TheSpiceAndRice
    TheSpiceAndRice
    2 days ago

    I was waiting for part where he would say he was being sarcastic 😐. Very disappointed, this movie just didn’t do it for me.

  12. Emilio Linares
    Emilio Linares
    2 days ago

    Being a side of the sea, middel of nowhere, full of old people AND Italian, the everyone just accepting the rest as fish monsters part was a bit... yeah... unrealistic... but (I know schaffrillas would me for this excuse) it's a kids movie, fuck it, let them have a happy ending

  13. N. H.
    N. H.
    2 days ago

    Idk bro... They're like, kids.... They make mistakes and are unlikable...... Alberto getting self conscious and jealous was pretty believable. The climax was pretty good as well idk

  14. CrimsonCoco•クリムソンココ
    CrimsonCoco•クリムソンココ
    2 days ago

    “He’s justifiably afraid of losing him to the heteros”

  15. J ack
    J ack
    2 days ago

    Is it strange I never cried watching a moive

  16. Dark Void
    Dark Void
    3 days ago

    I thought this movie was alright and good waste of my time

  17. Funtrap
    Funtrap
    3 days ago

    5:49 Those were my thoughts exactly!

  18. The Engineer
    The Engineer
    3 days ago

    He had us in the first quarter not gonna lie

  19. stefano franzini
    stefano franzini
    3 days ago

    you order PASTA?

  20. Twisted4kStudios
    Twisted4kStudios
    3 days ago

    I liked the movie a lot, but yeah, I feel like it could've been so much more; if the climactic scene wasn't just some race to win a trophy but instead maybe all the fisherman going on some mass hunt for the sea monsters, if we got to know more about Guilia and his dad (maybe a long time ago he fell in love with a woman that TURNED OUT to be a sea monster and she had to leave, and he's mad but that's also why he grows attached to Roberto, etc.), if the whole "betrayal" scene had a bigger pivot to the story instead of just a "hey, I'm sorry," Roberto: "Screw you" *then later just comes back with an umbrella*, and then if there was a longer transition and explanation of the humans no longer seeing the sea monsters as threats and so on... would've turned a good movie great, in my mind

  21. I’m Tired
    I’m Tired
    3 days ago

    I feel like Alberto behaving the way he did makes sense for someone of his age (14). He was struggling with the idea of losing the only real person in his life and he acted immaturely as a response. I can see from an adults standpoint how it’s “too much” but you really can’t expect an early teenager to be emotionally mature. And putting him in mortal danger isn’t really what he deserved. This review is good for the most part but I didn’t like that take, I think it’s hard sometimes for adults to understand why a kid isn’t acting, well, like an adult (this is a common problem with Aang, he’s twelve and people get mad at him for acting twelve). You need to view it through the lens of a kid, not a parent.

  22. Bretton Scrima da Roma
    Bretton Scrima da Roma
    3 days ago

    Wow. As "woke" as you are, I'm surprised you mentioned nothing about the cast not being Italian. How come the rules are different for us?

  23. sof 🌙
    sof 🌙
    3 days ago

    7:20 ah yes, the country roads ghibli movie

  24. Rayneworld
    Rayneworld
    4 days ago

    I dunnooooo, I watched this with friends last night, and this movie asked you to not question a LOT of plotholes. It needed way stronger world building, but ig they didn't have time for it which I get. It also felt not on par with Disney, Pixar, Dreamworks, etc, felt like a small company movie. Which btw I didn't hate it! I liked it, I just think it was fine.

  25. Allen Sickle
    Allen Sickle
    4 days ago

    Why is no one talking about the obnoxious switching between fake-accented English and badly-mispronounced Italian?

  26. Merletastic
    Merletastic
    4 days ago

    Luca made me feel. It made me feel happy, really happy.

  27. Project: Komodo
    Project: Komodo
    4 days ago

    *S I L E N Z I O B R U N O*

  28. A berry
    A berry
    4 days ago

    Can we talk about how Luca makes the " best friends have to their separate ways " trope so natural and well. It wasn't like some movies where it was out of the blue it felt natural that Luca wanted to go school and Alberto wanted to stay with his dad. The ending was honestly bittersweet and genuine, this movie is so cute and wholesome.

  29. Rafael C.R.
    Rafael C.R.
    4 days ago

    Mate, my brother made me see this video because he said "the best definition about Alberto is Schaffrillas' one: 'he doesn't want to lose Luca for the heteros'". I doubted him but YOU ACTUALLY SAID THAT!!

  30. Linaya Sehlstrom
    Linaya Sehlstrom
    4 days ago

    I will sue Disney if they don't make Luca x Alberto a thing. (I am legally obliged to say that is a joke)

  31. Anxiety Pancake
    Anxiety Pancake
    4 days ago

    I loved Luca, my favorite character is Giulia. The first time i watched it i cried so hard i nearly vomited (i’m not kidding i was dry heaving)

  32. Alyssa
    Alyssa
    5 days ago

    Okay, usually I agree with most of the opinions in your videos, but I think that there’s a another perspective that can be seen here. As a queer person, this movie wasn’t just a lighthearted, fun adventure with a simple goal to complete. To me, it was a clear metaphor of the experiences of many people in the lgbtq community. The wanting to be free to make your own choices, the fear that followed them everywhere, the bullies, the scene where Luca turned on Alberto to protect himself, and the eventual acceptance from the human community were all so emotional to me because I saw it reflected in myself, and I know that many others saw it reflected in them, too. I’m obviously not saying that your opinions here are wrong or not valid, I just wanted to point out how different perspectives can add a whole new depth to the movie!

  33. Krueger Pool The 13th
    Krueger Pool The 13th
    5 days ago

    I actually appreciate one line in the end from the grandma saying that certain humans won’t accept him It was a very simple way to say:”yes, there is hate in the world, it exists” it really stuck with me

  34. Scavenger Rx
    Scavenger Rx
    5 days ago

    The Animations looks like its was kinda rushed, but i mean i isnt really a HUGE movie

  35. Iron Man
    Iron Man
    5 days ago

    Tbh I really like a movie that people don't like. Cars 2. And you might not agree but, Cars 2 was the best of the cars trilogy.

  36. SLAS S
    SLAS S
    5 days ago

    Disney make no bad movies

    1. Allen Sickle
      Allen Sickle
      4 days ago

      That's your nostalgia talking. Most of Disney's movies are riddled with plotholes and make no sense. Pixar movies are better, though.

    2. Krueger Pool The 13th
      Krueger Pool The 13th
      5 days ago

      Literally every sequel to an animated Disney movie is bad And Pixar movies don’t count

  37. Mr paws 54
    Mr paws 54
    5 days ago

    I watch this with my best friend 5 feet apart cause we’re not gay and we had a fucking blast also do monsters at work

  38. Ly Liz
    Ly Liz
    5 days ago

    Luca is like H2O mermaids, that was in my head while watching them trying not to get wet.

  39. Pigeon cookie
    Pigeon cookie
    5 days ago

    me: watches this video. also me: cried when the city finds out alberto is a see monster and luca saves alberto

  40. MattheJ1
    MattheJ1
    5 days ago

    "Nooo you can't just make a Pixar movie that isn't deep or thought-provoking!" "Hehe fish people go mama mia"

  41. Purplealchemist
    Purplealchemist
    5 days ago

    Luca gave me Studio Ghibli vibes, which wasn't a bad thing at all.

  42. Sally Soapy
    Sally Soapy
    5 days ago

    Ngl luca did make me cry and think aha

  43. Fūma
    Fūma
    6 days ago

    This movie made me cry tf lol 😂

  44. fe ,
    fe ,
    6 days ago

    They seem like really good friends

  45. Ben Dover
    Ben Dover
    6 days ago

    I don’t know why, but I REALLY like how the villain was a fully grown man instead of just a kid bullying the other kids. Usually we see the latter so it was kinda neat seeing something different. And plus it makes a lot more sense for the other kids to be intimidated by the antagonist, because he was a grown ass adult!

  46. Dreemurr Reality
    Dreemurr Reality
    6 days ago

    "losing him to the heteros" i rewatched this part of the video at least fifteen times lmao

  47. Thomas Jenkins
    Thomas Jenkins
    6 days ago

    I really love this movie love how it's essentially just a movie about summer friends and growing up.

  48. john aplin
    john aplin
    6 days ago

    I haven’t seen Luca yet but I think I will like it and am excited to see it especially because it’s not a soul but I do like these kinds of Pixar movies just so long as they are fully developed and realized because that’s how I felt about Onward and it still makes me mad because that had so much potential wasted

  49. TumbleBell
    TumbleBell
    6 days ago

    I respectfully disagree with your opinion on Alberto’s jealousy The trauma of having a parent up and leave you really does F you up, and causes you to act out in harsh ways to have control. In my opinion, it was very well written, and i agree with a lot of what you said apart from this one bit :)

  50. GARRET BRADY
    GARRET BRADY
    6 days ago

    I kinda liked that they didn't push hints of a gay relationship. It was nice to just see another movie with just two boys being friends and having fun.

  51. Raven Wolf
    Raven Wolf
    6 days ago

    The dad 100% silently threatened the townspeople to accept the boys. You know that no one is going to object when someone like /him/ says something, they know what will happen to them if they do. He's not exactly shy about brandishing his weapons, and he didn't need to actively say anything for his threats to go through.

  52. maddie
    maddie
    6 days ago

    i love this movie so much. and even though its not totally confirmed, i think we all know that luca and alberto have something going on

  53. sobbles
    sobbles
    6 days ago

    u should make a video on if u think the movie had lgbtq+ vibes to it and why a lot of people could feel that way. i would love to here ur opinion on the matter and i think it would make for a great video seau g how much the comment section is ONLY talking about that

  54. therapy friend
    therapy friend
    6 days ago

    "six feet apart cause theyre not gay" *press x to doubt*

  55. That1guy
    That1guy
    7 days ago

    I dunno man I liked Brave and Onward

  56. Ultomato Souper
    Ultomato Souper
    7 days ago

    Slice of Life movie

  57. Astral Skye
    Astral Skye
    7 days ago

    The second time I watched it I did notice the reaction of the town for accepting the sea monsters. It did seem a little quick but it made me think how long where those two older women staying in that town while hiding they were sea monsters.

  58. Gluten
    Gluten
    7 days ago

    “It doesn’t have to change the world” yet has broken 100s of molds, represented several groups and reversed loads of cliches, as well as going against the “Pixar” model for a movie by being so simple

  59. Gluten
    Gluten
    7 days ago

    Sometimes we just need a feel good movie… when you expect to cry watching a movie it loses its meaning

  60. Mustafa Ahmed
    Mustafa Ahmed
    7 days ago

    Brov, I loved Luca-seen it twice already

  61. yeet
    yeet
    7 days ago

    man...me and schaff really do not agree on much of anything movie wise.

  62. yeet
    yeet
    7 days ago

    me starting this video: :) Me when he said he thinks brave was a bad movie: :( (obviously I get that it's just an opinion but I thought it was a really nice movie)

  63. Syd the kid
    Syd the kid
    7 days ago

    This movie was one of my favorite Pixar movies. Just because Luca is such a relatable character, and the animation was too beautiful. Not because of the story, though. The lesson learned and the storyline wasn't amazing, but it was so good anyhow.

  64. Lizu Mai
    Lizu Mai
    7 days ago

    This movie made me happy. It made my gay little heart light up AND THE DAMN ANIMATION IS SO PLEASING AND BEAUTIFUL THE CHARACTER DESIGNS, THE SCENERY, EVERYTHING.

  65. Aflahul Falihin • 78 years ago
    Aflahul Falihin • 78 years ago
    7 days ago

    Dad's Cleaver has bloods DAD'S CLEAVER HAS BLOODS BLOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOODS!!!!!!!!!!

  66. Mr Dino Otaku
    Mr Dino Otaku
    7 days ago

    "Luca is gae" "SILENZIO BRUNO"

  67. TalesOfRandolph
    TalesOfRandolph
    7 days ago

    In my opinion, this movie has a refreshing level of complexity that doesn't come from the setting or plot of the film but rather its characters. Rather than focusing on the race or hunting fish, the story itself is about the two boys friendship. Throughout the film we see Luca and Alberto become closer and closer, only to be slowly ripped apart by there different ambitions. The emotional complexity, for a kids film, is very mature and easy to follow. Not only this but the characters themselves have such an adorable friendship that you cant help but smile when they share screen time. Going into the movie, if you focus on not necessarily the plot or the race and rather the growing love the two characters build for one another, the movie appears a heck of a lot stronger. So much so I watched it three times in a two week span at one point.

  68. Izuku Midoriya that simps for Ochako
    Izuku Midoriya that simps for Ochako
    7 days ago

    Friendly reminder that Luca and Alberto are straight

  69. Insight Zoidberg
    Insight Zoidberg
    7 days ago

    nah

  70. Keith Gabrielson
    Keith Gabrielson
    8 days ago

    Personally disagree with this, I think it was a very emotionally compelling movie.

  71. Celadon
    Celadon
    8 days ago

    I liked this movie. It's not a fantastic movie, sure, but I quite liked it. It's nice and simple but gave me that warm and fuzzy feeling. It's a comforting feeling.

  72. Trey Tipton
    Trey Tipton
    8 days ago

    I love all of your videos and agree with most of your opinions but I will never be able to get on board with you saying onward is a bad movie. It’s in my top 5 Pixar movies

  73. Skullbaster
    Skullbaster
    8 days ago

    You should do secret magic control agency. I tought the mouvie was but i am interessted to see what you think

  74. Uncertain Zee
    Uncertain Zee
    8 days ago

    I didn't mind it not being gay, because 1) i think it was still relatable for some gay people, but 2) showing a close friendship between 2 boys is still such a nice, wholesome, and rare thing. I have a much older brother and watched the movie with my mom, who's told me many stories of my brother's funnier little blunders when he was a kid, and we would burst out laughing at many parts, especially at Alberto pretending to know everything and Luca just going with it because my brother had a friend like that, it was cute and fun and i cried regardless because it was just so charming. And personally, i really liked the final act.

  75. Sweet “What in the Goddamn?” Tea
    Sweet “What in the Goddamn?” Tea
    8 days ago

    Move away Disney. At least Dosney has the balls to commit with gay representation.

  76. Austin and Lucas's Channel
    Austin and Lucas's Channel
    8 days ago

    This is probably my most favorite Pixar movie

  77. ZombieBrideXD Animations and Art
    ZombieBrideXD Animations and Art
    8 days ago

    6:18 is that a jojo reference?

  78. Janelle oduro
    Janelle oduro
    8 days ago

    isn't this just a replica of the little mermaid. SHE goes on shore as a human and wants to marry the prince ( she wants something ). Disney and pixar are just becoming less and less creative. Like cruella was just disney making something that already was.

  79. Carmen Tin
    Carmen Tin
    8 days ago

    This movie is absolutely wonderful with heartfelt moments that make you leave the theatre feeling all kinds of emotions!! While the story is very simple and straightforward, the beats of this movie hit so well with its likeable characters and amazing soundtrack. Literally makes me wanna go to Italy right this instant!!!

  80. jacob rohde
    jacob rohde
    8 days ago

    Luca was up their with soul and coco wtfffff, it was great

  81. • rainchan-! •
    • rainchan-! •
    8 days ago

    Where can I watch the movie? I can't find any English dub, full movie and good quality ;-;

    1. Prismatic Guy
      Prismatic Guy
      7 days ago

      You can find it on Disney plus.

  82. lululemoncello -yt
    lululemoncello -yt
    8 days ago

    schaff, i think you should make a inside out vs soul. i always found soul as a sort of spiritual sucsessor to inside out

  83. niki
    niki
    8 days ago

    it's nah.

  84. Mr. Ham
    Mr. Ham
    8 days ago

    Hey schafrillas where would you rank this movie in the Pixar ranking

  85. Michimochi
    Michimochi
    8 days ago

    Alberto wasn’t being a douche, he was just scared that Luca would abandon him just like his dad did. He was so scared that Luca would forget about him and start hanging out with Guilia more. That betrayal scene wasn’t deserved, Alberto was just an adolescent boy who struggled in trying to talk about his feelings of inadequacy to Luca and shows how he feels by being salty and mean. Because of that, he was almost impaled with spears.

  86. Yellow Mario
    Yellow Mario
    8 days ago

    The weird thing is I found an ad on the above the next up area and it had the luca character and his friend showing a rainbow by them and it probably was saying their gay. Idk even know why that ad exits lol

  87. Jonah Kluger
    Jonah Kluger
    8 days ago

    I felt pretty much the same, it's not a life changing experience that had me thinking after watching it, but it was cute. As you mentioned, I like how they didn't turn everything into drama. Giulia's parents wasn't a conflict but instead a natural plot device, all the characters were close friends and nothing more, the dad just being born without an arm, etc etc. I'll always say I prefer an Evangelion to a Konosuba, but both are absolutely lovely for different reasons. If Up or Wall-E is an Evangelion, Luca is a Konosuba.

  88. Riku Tamura
    Riku Tamura
    8 days ago

    one of my fav pixar movies

  89. Reload mania
    Reload mania
    8 days ago

    Hey I have a different opinion about this movie but in still love your channel

  90. newford
    newford
    8 days ago

    you're sussy

  91. Itzel Montalvo
    Itzel Montalvo
    8 days ago

    Am I the only one that got Studio Ghibli vibes from the movie?

  92. ThatFamiIiarNight
    ThatFamiIiarNight
    8 days ago

    This took 2 days. Boss baby 2 came out 15 days ago. WHERE’S THE FUCKIN REVIEW OF IT

  93. ʕ·ᴥ·ʔ
    ʕ·ᴥ·ʔ
    8 days ago

    "Losing him to the heteros" 😆

  94. ‡ Gothic Croc ‡
    ‡ Gothic Croc ‡
    9 days ago

    They’re confirmed cousins.

  95. Crystal OBar
    Crystal OBar
    9 days ago

    What

  96. M. Banerjee
    M. Banerjee
    9 days ago

    Alberto said things that Luca needed to hear, I don't think pointing out the truth makes him a jerk. Luca literally could have gotten him killed.

  97. SirHideki
    SirHideki
    9 days ago

    3:42 I love designs like that and always will.

  98. Caterina Pietronudo
    Caterina Pietronudo
    9 days ago

    I was underwhelmed watching this movie, but as someone who’s Italian I am really happy so many people enjoyed it and found it charming. It is a charming movie -just not my cup of tea.

  99. capt_toad7890
    capt_toad7890
    9 days ago

    I don't know what my problem was. I was too distracted by the weird art style and uncanny expressions and movements to connect.

  100. Leonardo Magri
    Leonardo Magri
    9 days ago

    I liked it a lot, but as an Italian I found it a bit too stereotypical...that is what the American audience wants I guess.